Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (2024)

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (1)

When you think of must-have wardrobe essentials, tank tops likely come to mind. And it makes sense—tank tops lay the foundation for a great look, says stylist Jennifer Nisan. “Tank tops are a wardrobe builder; I suggest always having one in white, black, and gray in your closet," she explains.

The Best Deals on Tank Tops

Being a wardrobe staple only means one thing: Every brand has one. And while we love that there are plenty of options available, not all tops are made equal. To help you narrow down the best tank tops, we conducted hours of research, evaluating each option based on sizing, colors, materials, and price. Then, we consulted with fashion stylists we trust. The result: A curated list of top-rated tank tops that we recommend you check out.

In This Article

  • The Best Deals on Tank Tops

  • Our Picks

  • Where We Stand

  • What To Look For

  • FAQ

  • Why Trust Byrdie

Made from compressive and stretchy rib cotton, this scoop neck tank is designed for maximum comfort and a fit that looks great on every body shape. It comes in the basic colors you’ll want in your wardrobe (like Heather Grey, Black, and White) and acts like the Goldilocks of tank tops—not too long, not too short, not too thin, not too thick. Plus, the tank is available in sizes XS through 5X, leaving little to be desired.

Size Range: XS–5X | Colors: Heather Grey, Black, White | Material: 100% cotton

Best Budget

Gap Modern Tank Top

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (3)

With plenty of glowing reviews, this tank top is sure to be your new go-to. Not only is it inexpensive, but it’s stretchy yet structured and comes in five colors, so you can count on it as a comfortable and versatile addition to your rotation. The best part: This style has petite, regular, and tall options, so most people will be able to secure a perfect fit.

Size Range: XXS-2X | Colors: Light Heather Grey, Black +more | Material: 58% cotton, 39% modal, 3% spandex

Best Splurge

Reformation Julia Rib Tank Top

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (4)

$98 for a tank top might be a splurge, but like the rest of Reformation's offerings, this style's high-quality craftsmanship makes this a sound fashion investment. The Julia Rib Tank Top is super soft (made almost completely with organic cotton) and has a square neck that suits everyone, regardless of bust size. We relaly like the thick, sweater-like material, too, as it adds to the elegance of the top and allows you to wear a bra underneath without worrying about lines.

Size Range: XS-XL | Colors: Black, Ivory +more | Materials: 92% organic cotton and 8% nylon

Best Black

Everlane Supima Sleeveless Top

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (5)

This classic black tank just might be your go-to layering piece. Made of extra fine Supima cotton, this tank top is as soft as it is versatile. Featuring the perfect blend of stretchiness and thickness, it hugs the body seamlessly without any visible lines or creasing. Keep in mind that it's slightly cropped, so it’ll likely hit just at your waist.

Size Range: XXS-XL | Colors: Black, Heathered Grey +more | Material: 92% SUPIMA® Cotton, 8% Elastane

Best Athletic

Alo Yoga Seamless Chosen Tank

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (6)

This subtly ribbed tank is perfect for yoga, sure, but is also great for everyday wear, too. It’s fitted and full-length (meaning it'll tuck into whatever you pair it with) and works well no matter what you're up to, from sweating it out in the gym to layering under a blazer. It’s been wear-tested by the Alo team so it’s practically guaranteed to fit just right.That said, we would love to see the brand expand its sizing to include even more sizes.

Size Range: XS-L | Colors: Black and White | Material: Seamless lightweight cotton with piqué texture

This classic scoop-neck tank comes in sizes XXS through 4X, and thanks to the fact that it has a good stretch to it, it's a great option for just about everyone. We're big fans of the ribbed texture (which only adds to the coziness) and the hip-grazing cut. Whether you wear it out, to lounge around, or even throw it on before bed, chances are you'll become as obsessed as we are.

Size Range: XXS-4X | Colors: Heather Grey, Onyx +more | Materials: 91% modal and 9% spandex

Best Double-Layered

Reformation Myles Tank

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (8)

Layering tank tops is so 90's—and now it's back, we're here for it. This double-layered tank top from Reformation leans into the vintage look, adding interest to everyday wear. The slim-fitting top hits slightly above the waist, and pairs well with bottoms of any kind (jeans, maxi skirts, the works). As for fabrication, this top is made with an eco-friendly stretch fabric that’ll move with you as you go about your day—talk about supreme comfort.

Size Range: XS-XL | Colors: Black and White | Materials: 97% organic cotton and 3% spandex

Best Long

Abercrombie Essential Rib Tuckable Scoopneck Tank

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (9)

Abercrombie’s super-soft slim-fitting tank is long enough to tuck (and stay tucked!), which makes it a great option to pair with trousers or high-waisted jeans. The 90s-inspired scoop neck will highlight your décolletage—without being too much of a plunge—and offers a clean silhouette in a bunch of different colors.

Size Range: XXS-XL | Colors: Light Grey, Black +more | Materials: 95% cotton and 5% elastane

Best Cropped

REORIA Racer Back Tank

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (10)

Get this tank in every color and you’ll have so many easy outfit options. This cropped tank is ideal for layering or wearing with high-waisted items for a proportional fit. It’s soft and breathable, plus it’s double-lined so nothing shows through. One reviewer called it the best tank top they’ve ever owned.

Size Range: S–2X | Colors: Black, White +more | Material: 84% polyester, 16% spandex

Best Built-in Bra

V for City Women’s Tank Top

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (11)

This tank top has a built-in shelf bra and a breathable fabric that makes it great for layering. The bra isn’t padded, but it serves as another layer that gives boobs support while the adjustable straps ensure everything is secured in place.

Size Range: S-5X | Colors: Black, Brown, +more | Material 95% cotton and 5% spandex

Best Plunge

Verdusa Double V Tank Top

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (12)

Verdusa's plunge option, which features a deep V in both the front and back, is ultra stretchy and supportive. Our advice: Wear it with a button-up shirt, jeans, and heels for a classy, yet sexy, look. Another bonus? It comes in four different colors so you can wear it over and over again.

Size Range: XS–2X | Colors: Black, Brown +more | Material: 92% rayon, 8% spandex

Best Muscle

Athleta Seamless Muscle Tank

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (13)

If you’re looking for more of a muscle tank cut, look no further. This one from Athleta is seamless and has a slightly fitted vibe for a bit of an elevated look. Wear it to workout or wear it any other time—it’s a classic. Did we mention the fabric is odor-minimizing? Yeah. *Buys immediately*

Size Range: XXS-XL | Colors: Grey Heather, White +more | Materials: 100% recycled polyester

Best Seamless

Free People Clean Lines Muscle Cami

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (14)

We think we're in love. This Free People tank offers super clean, structured lines that really work to chic-ify your normal, everyday tank top. It’s form-fitting, hitting at the hip, and comes in a ton of colors so you’ll definitely be buying more than one. Oh, and it has a built-in bra for extra support.

Size Range: XS-XL | Colors: White, Heather Grey +more | Materials: 92% nylon and 8% spandex

Best Workout

The Giving Movement 2-in-1 Asymmetric Softskin100© Tank & Sports Bra

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (15)

If you're looking for a tank top fit that brings the drama, this asymmetrical option is for you. The shape is eye-catching and unique, and it comes in 12 vibrant colors (like Emerald Green, Midnight Plum, and Mustard—just to name a few) to pair with many outfits.

Size Range: XS-XL | Colors: Black, Green, +more | Materials: 80% recycled polyester and 20% recycled spandex

Best Knit

Madewell Textured-Stitch Sweater Tank

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (16)

Madewell is known for making classic pieces that become wardrobe staples, and this knit tank top is no different. It's made of a cotton blend for maximum comfort and is designed to stop between your belly button and upper hip. Layer this tank during the winter months, or let it stand alone when it's warmer out.

Size Range: XXS-2X | Colors: Cream, Khaki | Materials: Cotton, acrylic, polyester

Best Silk

J. Crew Carrie V-Neck Camisole In Silk

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (17)

Silk makes everything look 10 ten times more elevated—and this J. Crew tank does just that and then some. Made of 100% silk, this tank is luxurious and lightweight—perfect for the summertime or layering. It also comes in several colors, from bright red to a classic polka dot pattern, to mix and match with any ensemble. The brand touts this shirt as the “desk-to-dinner top,” and we couldn’t agree more. The material makes it elevated for the office, but the slight plunge makes it a great dramatic dinnertime staple.

Size Range: XXS-3X | Colors: Ivory, Black, +more | Materials: 100% Silk

Where We Stand

Overall, our favorite tank top is the Good American Micro Rib Tank Top because the stretchy material is comfortable and looks great on every body type. We also love Gap Modern Tank Top because it’s inexpensive and comes in three fits.

What to Look for In Tank Tops

  • Fabric: Thicker fabrics are your friend when it comes to tank tops, so you'll want to avoid thin materials. “Tank tops are basics worth investing in, and you should have one that will stand the test of time, as well as multiple wears and washes,” says stylist Emily Men. “I always look for tank tops made from high-quality material—whether it's cotton, silk, or a blended fabric—because you want it to hold its shape.” (If you’re looking for a high-quality silk option, try the J. Crew Carrie V-Neck Camisole In Silk.) “This is especially important when you are wearing a white tank top so you can’t see your skin or bra underneath it,” says Nisan. “I also think a thicker fabric just creates a more elevated and sophisticated look.” For a knit option, consider the Madewell Textured-Stitch Sweater Tank.
  • Fit: “Avoid tank tops that are ill-fitting. If the straps are falling off, or if you find fabric bunching in the chest, that style is not for you,” says stylist Vanessa Powell. You want something that looks streamlined and versatile enough to layer under different pieces as needed. Or, you can save a step and get a double-layered tank top, like the Reformation Myles Tank.
  • Design: In terms of design, many tank top styles feature a narrow neckline and "don't allow for bra straps," says Nisan. So, if you want to wear a bra, we recommend a tank top like the Reformation Julia Rib Tank Top. Otherwise, you can opt for a strapless bra.

FAQ

  • What are some ways to style a tank top?

    There are so many ways to style a tank top, which is why it's one of the items everyone should have in their closet. “I love layering a ribbed tank top under a button-up T-shirt or a blazer while tucking it into belted trousers or jeans. It's polished but casual," Powell says. "Right now, thick rib high-neck crew tank tops are trending. My favorite way to style this formula is a creamy monochrome moment (think cream tank and white jeans)."

  • What should you wear over a tank top?

    You can basically wear anything with a tank top. “Tank tops are a great base that you can wear as a main part of your outfit, as an extra layer in the winter, or with a comfy sweatsuit when you're lounging," Men explains. "I currently love wearing a sheer blouse over a classic tank or with an open blazer draped over your shoulders." Nisan adds that an oversized button-down can look chic over a tank top, especially when worn in the same color. "A cardigan is a no-brainer with a tank top, too; I love the look of a light sweater draped and knotted over the shoulders—it's super elevated."

  • What bra should you wear with a tank top?

    It depends. “I usually recommend a strapless one (or one of those convenient convertible bras) unless you are going for a more deliberate look where you want the bra straps to show,” says Men. “Or if you hate bras like me, you can go without a bra and just wear nipple covers!”

Why Trust Byrdie

Samantha Leal is a lifestyle, fashion, and beauty journalist with more than 13 years of experience. She has been writing about fashion for more than a decade and has worked at publications like Marie Claire and Latina magazine. She’s tested tons of products, including tank tops, and has vetted suggestions from style experts.

Cullen Ormond is an editor whose work can be found on Apartment Therapy. She helped to ensure the tank top size ranges, colors, and materials were all up to date (and even added in a few of her favorites!). She believes in the value of a good tank top and thinks a well-fitting tank with a pair of jeans and some ballet flats is the ultimate cool girl look.

For this story, team Byrdie interviewed experts to gather more insights about what to keep in mind when buying tank tops. Those experts are:

Score Stylist-Approved Tank Tops From J. Crew, Free People, Everlane, and More, Up to 70% Off (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5885

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.